Judicial Reform in Mexico—or AMLO Power Play?

Home | HS Blog | Judicial Reform in Mexico—or AMLO Power Play? President Andrés Manuel López Obrador's (AMLO) proposed judicial reform in Mexico has sparked significant controversy. The primary aim is to reshape the country's legal system by increasing transparency, efficiency, and democratic accountability. However, the most radical proposal—popular election of judges—has raised concerns about potential risks to judicial independence and the overall functioning of the justice system Key Provisions of the Judicial Reform Popular Election of Judges: One of the most radical proposals is to allow citizens to directly elect Supreme Court justices, magistrates, and judges, an uncommon arrangement in Latin America, where judges tend to be appointed. This move is intended to make the judiciary more responsive to the people's needs. However, critics argue that it could politicize the judiciary and compromise judicial independence. Reduced Supreme Court: The size of the Supreme Court would be reduced from 11 to 9 justices, and their term limits would be shortened. Elimination of Life Pensions: To promote austerity and reduce government spending, the life pension for Supreme Court justices would be abolished. New Judicial Oversight Body: A new judicial administration body would be created to oversee the judiciary and ensure accountability. Streamlined Procedures: The reform aims to expedite legal proceedings and reduce case backlogs. Objectives and Controversies The stated objectives of the judicial reform include: Increased transparency and efficiency: By making the judiciary more accountable to the public and streamlining procedures, the reforms aim to improve the overall functioning of the justice system. Enhanced democratic legitimacy: Popular election of judges is seen as a way to increase public trust in the judiciary. Cost reduction: By eliminating life pensions and reducing the size of the Supreme Court, the government aims to save money. However, these reforms have faced significant opposition. Critics argue that: Judicial independence may be compromised: Popular election could lead to judges being influenced by political considerations rather than the law. Experienced judges may be lost: The elimination of life pensions could discourage talented individuals from pursuing a career in the judiciary. There are also concerns about the minimal qualifications required to be a judge under the proposed changes. Unintended consequences: The rapid pace of these reforms could lead to unintended consequences and disrupt the functioning of the justice system. Impact on the Legal System The proposed judicial reform has already had a significant impact on Mexico's legal system. A nationwide work stoppage by federal judges has brought many courts to a standstill, disrupting legal proceedings and raising concerns about access to justice. Conclusion While Mexico's judicial reform aims to increase transparency, efficiency, and democratic accountability, it has also raised concerns about over judicial independence and the overall functioning of the justice system. The most controversial aspect of the reform is the proposal to allow popular election of judges. While this could enhance public trust in the judiciary, it also carries the risk of politicizing the bench and compromising judicial independence. In any case, the election of judges in Mexico would be a novel development for the region, potentially setting a precedent for other Latin American countries. The nationwide work stoppage by federal judges in response to the proposed reforms highlights the significant disruptions that could result from these changes. The potential impact on litigants is particularly concerning, as delays in legal proceedings could have far-reaching consequences. Thank you to the lawyers at Rivadeneyra Treviño (our affiliated law firm in Mexico) for their informative update on the subject. Check Out Our Practice Areas Share Twitter Facebook LinkedIn E-mail Comment Fred Rocafort Fred leads Harris Sliwoski’s intellectual property practice and is the coordinator of the firm’s international team. Much of Fred’s practice consists of helping cannabis businesses protect their brands. He also works with entrepreneurs and companies entering the Web3 space, a new frontier for IP law. Prior to joining Harris Sliwoski, Fred worked overseas for more than a decade, in both government and private sector roles. Fred is a regular contributor to the award-winning China Law Blog and Canna Law Blog. Fred began his career overseas as a U.S. consular officer in Guangzhou, China, where he advocated for fairer treatment of American companies and citizens in China and for stronger intellectual property rights enforcement. After entering the private sector, Fred worked at a Shanghai law firm as a foreign legal advisor and later joined one of the oldest American law firms in China, helping foreign companies navigate the Chinese legal environment. He also led the legal team at a Hong Kong-based brand protection consultancy, spending most of his time out in the field, protecting clients against counterfeiters and fraudsters in Greater China, Southeast Asia and Latin America. In addition to his IP work, as a native Spanish speaker, Fred works closely with different Harris Sliwoski teams on Latin America and Spain matters. Fred also provides advice to cannabis industry participants and other businesses on import and export transactions. Fred is an ardent supporter of FC Barcelona—and would be even in the absence of Catalan forebears who immigrated to Puerto Rico in the mid-1800s. Harris Sliwoski Attorney Read more posts [email protected] Read More Latin America Related Posts May 18, 2026 Registering a Trademark in Venezuela: What International Businesses Need to Know March 31, 2026 Trademark Registration in Cuba: Why Companies Should Be Thinking Ahead September 26, 2024 FAQs on Mexico Data Protection Law September 25, 2024 Mexico's Data Breach Notification Statutes: A Comprehensive Guide May 22, 2024 A Mexico Company Formation Guide February 13, 2024 Registering Trademarks in Mexico: What You Need to Know March 10, 2022 Mexico Employment Law Basics January 20, 2022 U.S. Latinos Represent a Huge Opportunity for Mexican Businesses January 3, 2022 Moving Manufacturing to Mexico: The FAQs December 12, 2021 Mexico Representative Offices November 18, 2021 Family Business Succession Planning September 22, 2021 How to Buy Real Estate in Mexico as a Foreigner May 10, 2021 How to Form a Company in Mexico Leave a comment Cancel reply